There are many things about Sotomayor that people are discussing; her background as a Latina from a poor family in the South Bronx is a source of both inspiration and criticism. However, I have yet to see a focus on her Catholic school education and the implications it has for school choice and Catholic schools.
Catholic schools were created to serve the disadvantaged and continue to do so to this day, yet their history, challenges, and successes are largely unknown. For example, in NYC, where 11% of students attend Catholic schools, a letter was recently sent to all Catholic schools by the Archdiocese of NY celebrating how Catholic school students outperformed public school students on the New York State English Language Arts Exam (again). We also know that students graduating from Catholic high schools in NYC have a 98% college attendance rate.
Well, I know this. I know this because I work at a Catholic school and am a product of Catholic education so this information is shared freely among those in the Catholic circle. But of course the public wouldn’t know this because in the growing discussion about school choice, Catholic schools are absent. The debate is generally about charter schools and when Catholic schools are mentioned it is to highlight how many of them are closing.
The issue facing Catholic schools is largely a financial one stemming not just from competition from other schools (many of whom have adopted an approach to teaching that Catholic schools have been using for years) but also from lack of public support and awareness of the work we do. We know that New York City cannot absorb all of the students suddenly without schools yet little is being done to ensure that their families have access to the schools that they wish to attend.
When Obama sent his daughters to a private school, discussions about the state of public schools—especially in DC—became more intense. Now that we have someone heading to Capitol Hill with a catholic education under her belt, will new conversations take place? Will Catholic schools have a greater presence in the school choice debate? Will their successes and challenges be discussed with the public at large? I hope so—many children and their families are depending on it.
Interesting reads:
Can Catholic Schools Be Saved?
To Save NYC’s Catholic Schools
Catholic-School Closing Tragedies
The words “history,” “change,” and “hope” have made their rounds in virtually every media outlet around the world in an attempt to describe President Obama. We feel good as a country knowing that we have made a huge step forward. It takes a lot for a nation to elect someone from a group that it has for so long despised and abused. His election should not be taken lightly in that regard yet it should not be taken as a signal that we are now a completely equal society. I have loved his campaign, his election, and his swearing in because of the conversations that have been sparked.